Next week the sales begin in earnest. Black Friday lands the day after Thanksgiving, and for many families the season of gift buying starts at the same time. Most of us think hard about what to buy. Far fewer of us think about what happens if it has to go back.
That matters more than it sounds. The National Retail Federation reported in October 2025 that retailers expected about 17 percent of holiday sales to be returned. That is roughly one gift in six. A few minutes of planning now can save you a long line, a lost refund or a frustrating argument at the counter in January.
Know this first: a return is usually a policy, not a right
Many shoppers assume every store must take things back. In general, that is not how it works. The Michigan Attorney General’s consumer office explains that when a store posts a no-return policy, the law generally does not require it to accept returns unless the item is defective. Rules can differ from state to state, so check your own state’s consumer protection office if you are unsure.
The good news is that most stores do offer returns. The terms are simply set by each seller, which is why reading them ahead of time pays off.
Before you buy: five questions to ask
- How long is the return window? The Federal Trade Commission notes that windows vary, with some stores allowing 30 days and others 90. Some stretch holiday windows into January, and some allow no returns at all.
- Cash, card or store credit? Some stores refund your money. Others give only store credit, especially for gift-receipt returns.
- Is there a restocking fee? Michigan’s consumer office notes that some electronics sellers deduct about 15 percent for opened items such as laptops and cameras, and special-order items can carry higher fees.
- Who pays return shipping? For online orders, the FTC suggests checking whether you or the seller covers postage, and whether you can return the item to a local store instead.
- Does the box need to stay sealed? Video games, movies, software and computer gear often cannot be returned once opened.
If a website has no clear return policy posted, take that as a caution sign. Ask the seller for the policy in writing before you pay.
Set up a simple “receipt home” this weekend
Here is an easy family habit for the season. Pick one spot for every receipt, packing slip and order confirmation from now until New Year’s. It can be a large envelope on the fridge, a folder in a kitchen drawer, or an email folder named “Holiday 2026.” Snap a photo of paper receipts on your phone too, since thermal paper can fade.
When you buy a gift, ask for a gift receipt and tuck it into the card or box. That small slip lets the person you love exchange a wrong size without awkwardness, and without you having to reveal what you paid.
Keep tags on and boxes in good shape until the gift has been opened and enjoyed. Some stores accept returns only with original packaging.
When it is time to return something
Go sooner rather than later. Bring the item, the receipt, the original packaging and a photo ID, since the FTC notes some stores ask for all of these. Without a receipt, you may be offered store credit at the item’s lowest recent sale price, which can be far less than what was paid.
If the store’s deadline has passed and the item is defective, the FTC suggests contacting the manufacturer, since a warranty may still help.
And if things go sideways, stay kind and calm. Ask politely for a manager, who usually has more authority to solve problems. If a store refuses to honor its own posted policy, or will not take back an item that is defective or not as described, you can file a complaint with your state attorney general. If you paid by credit card, you may also be able to dispute the charge with your card company.
Shopping online this season? These five habits to protect your family from holiday shopping scams pair well with a smart returns plan.
A word about honesty
Returns can tempt people to cut corners. The same NRF report found that 45 percent of consumers said “bending the truth” on a return was acceptable, and retailers estimated that 9 percent of all returns were fraudulent. Those losses push prices up for everyone and make policies stricter for honest families.
Our homes can model something better. When kids see us read the fine print, keep our receipts and tell the plain truth at the counter, they learn that money is managed with care and integrity. Slow, careful choices usually serve a family better than hurried ones.
“The thoughts of the diligent tend only to plenteousness; but of every one that is hasty only to want.” Proverbs 21:5 (KJV)
This season, may your gifts be chosen with love, your receipts be easy to find, and your heart be full of gratitude for the One who gives every good thing. Through every storm, we rise together.
What is your family’s best trick for keeping track of holiday receipts and gift returns?
Sources: National Retail Federation, “Consumers Expected to Return Nearly $850 Billion in Merchandise in 2025” (October 15, 2025); Federal Trade Commission Consumer Advice, “What to know about holiday gift returns” (December 28, 2023); Michigan Department of Attorney General, “Avoiding Unhappy Returns” (accessed November 21, 2026); Proverbs 21:5, King James Version, Bible Hub.





Leave a Reply