Private companies to watch
AnthropicIPO coming · Nasdaq: ANTGeneral IntuitionPrivateApptronikPrivateAyar LabsPrivateNuroPrivateStandard BotsPrivatePolymarketPrivate
Live better. Love deeper. Believe bigger.NewsletterSubscribe free
LATEST
, ,

Thanksgiving 1789: The Day a Fragile New Nation Stopped to Give Thanks

On Thursday, November 26, 1789, the young United States held its first national day of thanksgiving under the Constitution. Here is the story of how it came about, the debate behind it, and what it can teach our tables today.

An autumn table with small pumpkins, flowers and candles

When American families sit down to give thanks next Thursday, November 26, they will share a date with a very first. On Thursday, November 26, 1789, the young United States observed its first national day of thanksgiving under its new Constitution, set aside by President George Washington just months into his first term.

It was not a holiday of parades and football. It was a day of prayer and gratitude called by a country that was still fragile, still in debt, and still arguing with itself. That is exactly why the story is worth telling again.

A nation finding its feet

In the fall of 1789, the United States was barely a nation in practice. The Revolutionary War had ended only a few years earlier. The Constitution had just taken effect, Washington had been inaugurated that spring in New York City, and Congress was meeting for the very first time. There was no Washington, D.C., and no White House yet.

Even before Congress acted, Washington had privately asked James Madison in August how he might approach the Senate about a day of thanksgiving, according to Mount Vernon’s historians.

Not everyone agreed

On September 25, 1789, Representative Elias Boudinot of New Jersey asked the House to request that the president recommend “a day of public thanksgiving and prayer.” The idea did not pass without debate. The Papers of George Washington project at the University of Virginia records that Aedanus Burke of South Carolina objected that it was “mimicking of European customs.” Thomas Tudor Tucker, also of South Carolina, argued that the House “had no business to interfere” in what he saw as a religious matter better left to the states.

The supporters, pointing to biblical examples and to the thanksgiving days the Continental Congress had called during the war, won the vote. The Senate agreed the next day, and a joint committee carried the request to the president.

The proclamation

On October 3, 1789, signing “at the City of New York,” Washington issued the proclamation. He named Thursday, November 26, as the day, and sent copies to the state governors, asking them to share it. Newspapers across the country printed it.

The words are worth reading slowly. Washington asked the people to “unite in rendering unto him our sincere and humble thanks.” He listed reasons: God’s care for the people before independence, the outcome of the war, “the greatest degree of tranquillity, union, and plenty, which we have since enjoyed,” the peaceful way the new Constitution had been formed, and “the civil and religious liberty with which we are blessed.”

He did not stop at thanks. The proclamation also asked for humility, praying for God “to pardon our national and other transgressions” and to help the nation govern itself wisely and justly. Gratitude and honesty about shortcomings sat side by side.

“In every thing give thanks: for this is the will of God in Christ Jesus concerning you.”

— 1 Thessalonians 5:18 (KJV)

Thanks that turned into action

The day was widely observed. Churches held services, and many of them collected gifts for the poor. In Virginia, the state assembly asked its chaplain to preach on November 26. According to Mount Vernon, Washington attended services at St. Paul’s Chapel in New York and sent food and beer to people held in debtors’ prison. Two days after the holiday, his secretary, Tobias Lear, sent $25 from the president to a New York pastor, John Rodgers, to help the poor of his congregations, as recorded in the Washington Papers.

In other words, the first national Thanksgiving was not only about counting blessings. It was about sharing them.

What happened next

The 1789 proclamation did not create a yearly holiday. Thanksgiving days came and went for decades, set by different leaders on different dates. It was not until 1941 that Congress fixed Thanksgiving as the fourth Thursday in November. But the pattern Washington set, a day to stop, give thanks to God and remember those in need, has lasted.

Lessons for our tables today

  • Gratitude does not wait for perfect times. The country of 1789 was uncertain and divided, and its leaders gave thanks anyway.
  • It is fine to disagree kindly. Congress argued openly, then moved forward. Families can talk honestly at the table and still love one another.
  • Thanks and humility belong together. Washington’s proclamation thanked God and also asked forgiveness. That is a healthy model for any home.
  • Let gratitude reach someone else. Following the example of 1789, consider adding a gift to a food bank or a visit to a lonely neighbor to your holiday plans.

One idea for this year: before the meal, read a short line from the 1789 proclamation aloud, then let each person name one blessing and one person they would like to help. You will be joining a tradition that is 237 years old this Thanksgiving Day.

What is one blessing your family is thankful for this year, even in the middle of a hard season?

Sources: George Washington’s Mount Vernon, “Thanksgiving” (The First President); George Washington’s Mount Vernon Digital Encyclopedia, “Thanksgiving”; George Washington’s Mount Vernon, “Thanksgiving Proclamation of 1789”; The Papers of George Washington (University of Virginia), “Thanksgiving Proclamation”; Founders Online/National Archives, editorial note to circular to the states, October 3, 1789; National Archives, Prologue blog, “A Thanksgiving Presidential Proclamation” (November 22, 2017); Teaching American History, “Thanksgiving Proclamation”; KJV 1 Thessalonians 5:18.

About the author: Jonathan Anthony Burkett is the founder of Upstormed News and Upstormed Inc, an author and songwriter. Meet our team · Our editorial standards · Report a correction

Never miss a story

Get our free Daily Briefing every morning, and follow Upstormed News for breaking news and uplifting stories.

Related stories

Join the conversation

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Discover more from Upstormed News

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading