Private companies to watch
AnthropicIPO coming · Nasdaq: ANTGeneral IntuitionPrivateApptronikPrivateAyar LabsPrivateNuroPrivateStandard BotsPrivatePolymarketPrivate
Live better. Love deeper. Believe bigger.NewsletterSubscribe free
LATEST

Home Insurance Premiums Rose 59% in 5 Years as Payouts Grew 28%, Advocates’ Report Says

A consumer advocates’ report finds U.S. home insurance premiums rose 59% from 2021 to 2025 while claim payouts rose 28%. Industry data show insurers only recently returned to profit after years of losses.

Houses with glass windows and chimney

Home insurance has become one of the biggest costs of owning a home, and a new report argues homeowners are getting less back for their money. Premiums collected by U.S. home insurers rose 59% from 2021 to 2025, while claim payouts rose 28%, according to a report released Nov. 19 by consumer advocacy groups led by Americans for Financial Reform. The insurance industry, for its part, points to several years of heavy losses before its recent return to profit.

What the report found

The report, titled “Home Insurers Are Ripping People Off Amid the Climate Crisis,” was published by the Americans for Financial Reform Education Fund with Public Citizen and the Revolving Door Project, Common Dreams reported. It analyzed industry data from the National Association of Insurance Commissioners covering 2021 through 2025, according to Inman.

  • Premium revenue grew from about $114 billion in 2021 to $181 billion in 2025.
  • Insurers paid out about 69 cents in claims per premium dollar in 2021 and about 55 cents in 2025.
  • About 30% of claims were closed without payment over the five years, and more than 22% of payments were delayed beyond 60 days.
  • In Florida, premiums rose 64% to $18.7 billion while claim payouts fell 67%. In Texas, premiums rose 78% while payouts fell 23%.

The groups estimate insurers earned $113 billion in “excess” underwriting income. That figure is measured against a benchmark in which insurers pay out 80 cents of every premium dollar in claims, a standard taken from a researcher’s proposal rather than a regulatory rule, the report notes. Alex Martin of the Americans for Financial Reform Education Fund said families are “paying too much for home insurance and getting less back,” according to Common Dreams.

The groups call for a minimum loss ratio for property insurers, tighter oversight of rate increases and claims handling, more transparency, and incentives for homeowners who strengthen their homes, Inman reported.

The industry picture

The report acknowledges that insurers cite climate change, inflation and reinsurance costs to explain higher rates, though it argues those factors do not fully explain the increases. Industry data show the business has swung back to profit only recently. AM Best reported a $16.5 billion homeowners underwriting gain in 2025, ending five straight years of underwriting losses, Insurify reported. In the first half of 2026, insurers spent 49 cents on claims per premium dollar, their best first-half result in more than a decade, according to Triple-I and Milliman data cited by Insurify. Insured catastrophe losses worldwide in the first nine months of 2026 were the lowest since 2019, Insurify said.

Price increases are slowing. AM Best put average premium increases at 4.3% in the first half of 2026, down from 7.6% in 2025 and 13.5% in 2024, Insurify reported. It projects the average annual premium will reach $3,057 in 2026, up 4% after a 12% jump in 2025, and up 46% since 2021. Results vary by state: Insurify projects a 16% rise in California and 13% in Nebraska, while 48 insurers in Florida have filed for rate decreases since January 2024.

Why insurance costs matter for home values

A separate report from property data firm Cotality, covered by Claims Journal on Nov. 16, warns that rising disaster risk is making coverage harder to get and putting pressure on home values. “Historical patterns no longer offer a reliable baseline for what’s to come,” the report said. It found Miami and Naples, Florida, and Houston are the U.S. cities with the most homes exposed to three major hazards over the next 30 years. In Dare County, North Carolina, 13% of policies were not renewed in 2023 and home values fell about 10%, though Cotality said that shows a link, not proof of cause.

Why it matters for families

For buyers, insurance can change what a home really costs each month, so it helps to get quotes before making an offer. For current owners, it is worth reviewing your policy at renewal. Insurify noted that insurers in storm-prone areas are adding separate wind or hurricane deductibles, and some pay only actual cash value, rather than replacement cost, for older roofs, which can leave owners paying more after a claim. Comparing quotes from more than one insurer and asking about discounts for roof upgrades or storm protection are common steps. This is general information only, not financial or insurance advice. Talk with a licensed insurance agent about your situation.

What to watch next

State regulators review rate filings, and the National Flood Insurance Program’s authority is tied to the Dec. 11 federal funding deadline. Upstormed News will keep following home insurance costs.

Related coverage

Read more: U.S. Rents Rise for First Time Since 2023 as Apartment Building Boom Fades

Has your home insurance bill gone up or down at your last renewal?

More real estate from Upstormed

Sources: Inman, “Home insurance premiums rose twice as fast as payouts over 5 years, report finds” (November 19, 2026); Americans for Financial Reform, “Home Insurers Are Ripping People Off Amid the Climate Crisis” (November 19, 2026); Common Dreams, “As Climate Crisis Worsens, Home Insurance Giants Rake In an Extra $113 Billion” (November 19, 2026); Insurify, “Home Insurers Are Making Money Again, But Not All Are Cutting Rates” (November 17, 2026); Claims Journal, “Report: Rising Disaster Risks Threaten Insurance Availability, Home Values” (November 16, 2026)

About the author: Jonathan Anthony Burkett is the founder of Upstormed News and Upstormed Inc, an author and songwriter. Meet our team · Our editorial standards · Report a correction

Never miss a story

Get our free Daily Briefing every morning, and follow Upstormed News for breaking news and uplifting stories.

Related stories

Join the conversation

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Discover more from Upstormed News

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading