A federal jury in Los Angeles on Friday found Jonathan Rinderknecht guilty of starting the fire that grew into the 2025 Palisades Fire, one of the most destructive wildfires in California history. The verdict came in a retrial, months after his first trial ended with a deadlocked jury.
Rinderknecht, a former Pacific Palisades resident, was convicted on both federal counts he faced: destruction of property by means of fire and arson. He had pleaded not guilty. According to the Associated Press, the jury reached its decision on the third day of deliberations, and Rinderknecht showed little reaction, hugging his attorneys before he left the courtroom.
What the jury decided
Prosecutors argued that Rinderknecht deliberately set a small brush fire, known as the Lachman Fire, in the early morning hours of January 1, 2025. They said the fire smoldered undetected in root systems underground for six days. On January 7, strong Santa Ana winds helped it flare back up, and it became the Palisades Fire.
That fire killed 12 people and destroyed neighborhoods in Los Angeles and Malibu. It burned more than 23,000 acres over roughly three weeks and destroyed more than 6,800 structures, according to reporting on the verdict.
For the retrial, the government obtained a new indictment and dropped a third charge involving timber set on fire. The remaining counts covered setting fire to government property and to property used in interstate commerce, NBC Los Angeles reported.
How prosecutors made their case
No witness or camera directly captured the moment the fire started, so the government built a circumstantial case. Prosecutors presented cellphone location data and photos of Rinderknecht’s car near the base of a trail, along with images from fire-detection cameras that they said showed the ignition window with no other people or vehicles approaching.
Expert witnesses testified that they had ruled out other ignition sources that night, including fireworks. Prosecutors also pointed to accounts from rideshare passengers and text messages describing Rinderknecht as angry in the days before the fire, and said he had a barbecue lighter in his car. They highlighted questions he typed into ChatGPT after the fire started, including whether a person is at fault if a fire is caused by their cigarettes, and argued he was trying to build an alibi.
In closing arguments, Assistant U.S. Attorney Danbee Kim urged jurors to “Piece it together. Look at it as a whole,” according to NBC Los Angeles.
What the defense argued
Defense attorney Steve Haney told jurors the case was largely circumstantial and that investigators had decided early on who was responsible. He argued that the fire scene may have been compromised because the area stayed open to the public until the Palisades Fire began, and he noted that lighter tests did not show sustained fire spread.
The defense also pointed to reports of fireworks and loud bangs on New Year’s Eve, a neighbor’s account of teenagers running from the trailhead, and phone records investigators did not obtain. A retired U.S. Forest Service fire investigator testified for the defense that the fire’s origin area differed from the government’s conclusion.
Why the retrial ended differently
Rinderknecht’s first federal trial, a two-week proceeding in June, ended in a mistrial after jurors deadlocked 10-2 in favor of acquittal. Prosecutors announced right away they would try him again, and the retrial began November 4.
One juror from the retrial, identified by the AP only by his first name, said he started deliberations as the lone vote for acquittal. He said Rinderknecht’s own testimony about being on the hill without noticing a fire or smoke was the strongest evidence that changed his mind.
What happens next
- Sentencing: U.S. District Court sentencing is set for March 17, 2027.
- Possible prison time: Each count carries a mandatory minimum of five years and a maximum of 20 years in federal prison, according to the AP.
- Appeal: Haney said the defense was disappointed but respected the jury’s process, and that it would review appeal options “at the right time.”
First Assistant U.S. Attorney Bill Essayli said his office was determined to hold Rinderknecht accountable. Some Palisades residents have said they believe other failures also contributed to how badly the fire spread, a debate that is likely to continue as recovery goes on. Upstormed News will follow the sentencing and any appeal.
Why it matters for families
Nearly two years after the fire, many Los Angeles-area families are still rebuilding homes, schools and routines. For many survivors, the verdict offers a legal answer about how the disaster started, even though it cannot undo the losses. The case is also a reminder for every household in wildfire country: know your evacuation routes, sign up for local emergency alerts, and keep a go-bag ready before fire season and wind events.
Related coverage
- California braces for atmospheric river, feet of Sierra snow before Thanksgiving
- Florida Digs Out From Record Flooding as Storm Heads Up the East Coast
Read more: Russia Pounds Ukraine With Massive Barrage as Europe Seeks Seat at Peace Talks
Has your family made a wildfire or emergency plan? Share your tips in the comments.
Sources: OPB / Associated Press, “Federal jury convicts man of starting the deadly 2025 Palisades Fire in Los Angeles” (November 21, 2026); NBC Los Angeles, “Man found guilty of starting Palisades Fire in federal prosecutors’ second attempt” (November 20, 2026); Daily Caller, “Man Found Guilty Of Starting Wildfire The Left Blamed On Climate Change” (November 21, 2026).





Leave a Reply